Is Christianity Oppressive?

True Faith in Jesus Liberates and Does Not Subjugate

Christianity claims to be a religion of love and compassion, yet some see it as a source of oppression.

Critics cite the Crusades, the Inquisition, complicity in slavery, colonialism, and the subjugation of women. Others point to more recent scandals: clergy sex abuse cover-ups, churches protecting predators instead of victims, and theologies used to silence survivors of domestic violence. These institutional failures of the church through the ages are undeniable and grievous. So it makes sense to ask:

Is Christianity simply a tool for control - used in God’s name to manipulate people, uphold the status quo, and silence dissent?

It's an important question that deserves a meaningful, straightforward answer.

It's also important for Christians to acknowledge that Christianity has, at times, been distorted into something ugly and unrecognizable. Whenever the church has aligned too closely with political power, as it did in the post-Constantinian era, abuses have followed. Greed, pride, and the human thirst for dominance crept in, overshadowing the humble, servant-hearted way of Jesus.

But the misuses and counterfeits of Christianity do not define or even resemble pure, actual Christianity. Jesus Himself railed against religious hypocrisy. His harshest words were for those who burdened others while elevating themselves. He said:

"They tie up heavy burdens, hard to bear, and lay them on people's shoulders, but they themselves are not willing to lift a finger to help with those burdens" (Matthew 23:4).

This isn't Jesus supporting those who control, oppress, and injure. It’s Him warning against and condemning all such behaviors.

At its core, Christianity proclaims freedom. In Luke 4:18, Jesus begins His public ministry by declaring:

"The Spirit of the Lord is upon Me, because He has anointed Me to proclaim good news to the poor… liberty to the captives… to set at liberty those who are oppressed."

The Gospel has never been about power lust, holding people back, or controlling them in Jesus’ name. It’s always been about setting people free - from sin, shame, fear, and injustice.

Jesus’ life was a protest against personal and systemic power used wrongly. He stood not just with the weak, but against systems that devalued them. He welcomed lepers, dignified women, embraced children, ate with sinners, and touched the untouchables. He healed on the Sabbath, knowing full well it would invite outrage from the religious establishment. He forgave and befriended prostitutes and challenged the social pecking order. He entered Jerusalem on a donkey, not a war horse. He washed His disciples’ feet and told them, "Whoever would be great among you must be your servant" (Mark 10:43).

Jesus didn’t wield a sword; He bore a cross. His final act was one of surrender and sacrifice - a suffering Servant, not a domineering ruler. This was, and is, a radical subversion of oppressive power.

---

This publication is free to all and sustained through reader support. If you wish to support Scott Sauls Weekly and receive bonus content:

---

The early church followed this pattern. Before Christianity gained any political influence, believers were a marginalized group, often persecuted. And yet, they lived counter-culturally for the good of all - rescuing abandoned babies, honoring women, and forming multicultural communities where status distinctions were broken down. Galatians 3:28 declared, "There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus."

The social vision of Jesus was revolutionary in a world built on hierarchy and privilege.

Of course, Christians have not always lived up to these ideals. But that gap between the ideal and reality points us back to Christ, not away from Him. When slavery was defended in the name of Christianity, it was believers like Hannah More and Olaudah Equiano who lifted their voices against it. More used her pen to sway hearts against human trafficking; Equiano used his story to awaken a nation’s conscience. They were not outliers, but faithful dissenters from within.

Today, similar voices rise up within the faith: theologians like Esau McCaulley advocating for racial reconciliation, and organizations like International Justice Mission confronting modern slavery with boots-on-the-ground resolve. Efforts to correct the misuse of Christianity continue to arise from within Christianity itself.

As Dorothy Sayers once said:

"The best remedy for a crooked stick is not to throw it away, but to use it to point straight."

Christianity also laid the groundwork for moral revolution. It introduced the radical concept that rulers are not above the law because they themselves are subject to a higher authority - God. It championed the sanctity of every life - not just those with status or strength. The first hospitals were founded and resourced by Christians, driven by a belief in the Imago Dei - that every human being is made in God’s image. Monasteries preserved literature and knowledge during chaotic centuries. Schools and universities emerged from Christian roots. Charity as a virtue gained prominence because Jesus redefined greatness as service. Even the modern separation of church and state - often cited as a guardrail against religious tyranny - has roots in Jesus’ teaching: "Render to Caesar what is Caesar's, and to God what is God's."

Consider Tertullian, writing in the 2nd century:

"It is a fundamental human right, a privilege of nature, that every man should worship according to his own convictions… It is assuredly no part of religion to compel religion."

This respect for freedom of conscience hasn't always governed the culture and practices of every tribe that has gone by the name, "Christian," but it has always been embedded in the true faith’s DNA.

Even in our time, Christian influence continues to challenge the mistreatment of people in the name of religion and irreligion alike. Churches in Iran risk their lives to meet in secret, defying unjust theocracy with the courage of Christ. Faith leaders in Myanmar continue to offer sanctuary during violent crackdowns. In the U.S., churches have become safe havens for immigrants facing deportation, and many congregations now advocate actively for survivors of abuse, mental health care, and restorative justice.

It’s also important to recognize that Christianity doesn’t just speak to big-picture, systemic oppression - it speaks to the personal kind too. A lot of people walk away from faith because they see it as nothing more than a heavy list of rules or an exhausting moral checklist. But that’s not the picture Jesus paints. In John 7:37, He says, “If anyone thirsts, let him come to Me and drink.” That’s not pressure, but a promise. It’s not a restriction, but an offer of renewal.

At its heart, real Christianity isn’t about control - it’s about God welcoming sinners and the weary to sit at His table. And then, in turn, His people learning to do the same. It’s not about tying people up in rules; it’s about setting them free. It’s not about managing and behavior and manipulating outcomes, but seeing hearts genuinely changed.

There’s a beautiful paradox at the heart of the Gospel: we find true life not by clinging to control, but by letting go. Freedom, in God’s economy, comes through surrender. Just as a guitar produces music not in spite of the tension in its strings but because of it, so too does the tension of obedience lead to a life that sings. Far from being a cage that oppresses and imprisons us, the call to follow Jesus is the pathway to our deepest flourishing. And when Christianity has been used to oppress rather than uplift, it hasn’t been an expression of Jesus - but a betrayal of Him.

The Gospel critiques all forms of unjust power. It tells leaders they will be held accountable, urges husbands to love sacrificially, calls parents to be gentle with their kids, and commands believers to break down every dividing wall of hostility. It doesn’t excuse or perpetrate injustice; it confronts it.

So, is Christianity another form of oppressive religion?
Only when it ceases to be truly Christian.
Only when it is a counterfeit masquerading as the real thing.

The faith founded by Jesus is a force for freedom - spiritually, socially, culturally, and personally. Its founder surrendered power to save. Its Scriptures call for justice and mercy. Its greatest moments have come not when the church grabbed for power and control, but when it laid down its life in sacrificial love.

For speaking inquiries, leadership coaching, or team enrichment, visit scottsauls.com.